CASE DETAILS

<< Back to Cases in IL

University of Illinois

Professor Kenneth Howell


Summary

For almost ten years, Dr. Kenneth J. Howell taught Introduction to Catholicism (and other classes) in the Department of Religion at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, consistently earning excellent—or even outstanding—marks on his student evaluations. In his class on May 3, 2010, he delivered a lecture outlining Catholic teaching regarding homosexual behavior, explaining how the Church distinguishes between same-sex attraction and homosexual conduct. He outlined how the Catholic Church teaches that homosexual conduct is morally wrong, framing the issue in the context of natural moral law. Though he covered this material in every semester, this lecture sparked an unprecedented reaction from students. So the next day, he sent the class an e-mail to help students understand how different moral systems would evaluate homosexual conduct. In the following weeks, Dr. Howell’s e-mail was circulated to various students, offices, and organizations within the University, often by people who were not even in his class. As a result, the University relieved him of his teaching responsibilities, without even giving him the opportunity to defend himself or explain his remarks. On July 12, 2010, the ADF Center for Academic Freedom sent the University a letter explaining that the First Amendment protects Dr. Howell’s right to teach Catholic doctrine in a class about Catholic doctrine. And it prohibits the University from removing him from the classroom simply because his speech was controversial.


Decision

WIN. The University of Illinois is reinstating Dr. Kenneth Howell as an adjuct professor this fall. In a letter to ADF, the University states that Dr. Howell will be asked to teach Introduction to Catholicism this fall. This is a tremendous win for Dr. Howell’s academic freedom and First Amendment rights.

Implications of Decision

The Supreme Court has yet to determine the full extent of professors’ free speech rights in the classroom. ADF is actively involved in cases protecting the rights of professors to express their views both inside and outside the classroom, free from discrimination because of their Christian or conservative views.

Case Documents


Professor Kenneth Howell Demand Letter.pdf

Professor Kenneth Howell_Letter from the University in response the Alliance Defense Fund demand letter.pdf

Professor Kenneth Howell_Second Letter from the Alliance Defense Fund to the University of Illinois.pdf



Related Media


E-mail complaint from student about UI religion instructor

E-mail that prompted complaint over UI religion class instructor

Instructor of Catholicism at UI Claims Loss of Job Violates Academic Freedom

University of Illinois Instructor Fired Over Catholic Beliefs

The Chronicle of Higher Education- Adjunct Who Taught Catholicism at U. of Illinois Says Job Loss Violated Academic Freedom

Illinois professor fired for giving Catholic teaching on homosexuality

U. of Illinois Fires Catholic Prof for Explaining Church Teaching on Homosexuality

Phi Beta Cons- Firing A Professor for Teaching His Subject?

U. of I. too quick to fire Catholic prof

A Further Update on Professor Howell: The University Spins

A Victory for Academic Freedom at the University of Illinois

Appeal planned by religious liberty group

University of Illinois Reinstates Instructor Fired Over Catholic Beliefs


Tell a Friend

Know someone who would like to know more about their religious rights on campus?

Tell a Friend how they can Speak Up

on Social Networks

© 2012 Alliance Defending Freedom. All Rights Reserved.

ADF
Contact Us | RSS Feed